23-06-18 Gotta little ketchup

Discuss Ma3 here!

Moderators: Dave Zero1, Don Alexander, Giz, midgetshrimp

User avatar
Error of Logic
Posts: 5649
Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2010 6:43 pm

Re: 23-06-18 Gotta little ketchup

Post by Error of Logic » Thu Jul 05, 2018 6:04 am

@ Vitocap: I'll admit, I phrased that unkindly, especially in light of later events. For what it's worth, I apologize.
In part, though, I was genuinely surprised you read the work of one of the older detective novelists.

User avatar
brasca
Posts: 3337
Joined: Wed Jul 13, 2011 6:04 am

Re: 23-06-18 Gotta little ketchup

Post by brasca » Fri Jul 06, 2018 1:58 am

@ Vitocap: Just block the trolls. It’s what I do to filter out the stupidity.

User avatar
Vitocap
Posts: 322
Joined: Thu May 12, 2016 5:02 am

Re: 23-06-18 Gotta little ketchup

Post by Vitocap » Tue Jul 24, 2018 2:12 pm

Today I stopped by to look at the Funny Bunnies, and thought I'd check my mail inbox. Talk about a surprise: ten "We'll miss you!" messages from ten different people! Thank you, all of you, you brought a tear to my eye. I want to share two of these messages, that really moved me a lot.
DarkAsh wrote:
Thu Jul 05, 2018 4:02 am
Your leaving is a punch in the stomach. It has been a pleasure reading your posts and learning from your interpretations of the on the stories, characters, and their possible motivations, and getting to know a little bit about you. Your absence will be a great loss to the forums. And It is sad that there is undoubtedly some out there who will see your departure as a boon to the forums.

I completely understand your frustration with the conditions of the forums as of late. I began posting because I enjoyed what I had been reading up to that point and it felt like a good place to converse with fellow enthusiast. But those with negative views have been the most vocal on the forums souring the experience. And that is not fair to those that enjoy the works of PTC and want to express our enjoyment of them.

If you find your self overwhelmed with delight for one of the pages and you want to express yourself, send me a message. I would be happy to listen.

Farewell, ghost of Pizen Bluff, may you find peace now that you are no longer condemned to roam the forum of torment.

DA.
worldshaking00 wrote:
Thu Jul 05, 2018 12:14 am
Sorry to see you go. Yes, at times the forum can get quite vitriolic and asinine. Sad state of affairs, but that is life. Going anywhere, one will wander into those who have differing and frustrating-to-deal-with opinions. I work with people - most of whom I wouldn't even want to know what postal code I live in - but I still have to deal with them. I say my peace, be polite, and move along. Life is too short for dealing with assholes.

I don't fault you for your decision. Sometimes complete removal might be necessary. My skin is just thicker than most... or my faith in humanity has dwindled to such a depth that I don't even care what written diarrhea some posters make. Net effect is the same: I am there because I enjoy expressing my point of view and I sometimes can be surprised by meeting others... and if I am lucky, become illuminated by a clever post(er). Sometimes that might mean having to wade through some offal. I find it rewarding, but I try to not feed the trolls too. Giving them a sense of satisfaction and giving them attention, only emboldens them more often than not. Ignoring them is good in concept; making them eat crow is another. Ideally a moderator would chastise or castrate the worst offenders. I grew up without the 'safe spaces' of today. I've learned to tune out the rabble noise, and only tend to really notice the blatantly rude ones. But as the guest in their forum 'house', it is not my job to call out people's behavior. Leaving, as sad as that might be, is an alternative... as is turning the cheek and ignoring.

Sayonara seems appropriate, considering our tastes in anime. :YMPEACE:
It comforts me to know that, in my few years in the forum, I did make a difference. I suspect that if it was someone like, say, Fluffy, nobody would miss her Bible-thumping rants.

One thing that several people mentioned in their messages is that moderation still hasn't reacted to the gross violations of forum etiquette I wrote about before. Something is really wrong here. They tell me Alex seems to be the only moderator still active. If that's the case, he sucks at moderating -- so much it's outrageous. The problem he's ignoring is not a minor one. We're talking here about loonies who accuse Giz and Dave of advocating racism, rape and pedophilia. We're talking about slut-shamers who call a pre-teen girl "a slut whose goal in life is to suck dick for dimes." We're talking about fan haters who unleash abuse at anyone who says they like the comics. None of these are tolerable in a forum. We know from exchanges in previous threads that the offensive messages were reported, that many people wrote directly to Alex, that there were public calls to action -- mine included... and yet, he hasn't lifted a finger. The mind, it boggles. What's wrong with his moderating? How can he suck so much? How can he fail so hard? These are questions that should be asked. Not by me, seeing as it ain't my concern anymore -- but by the forum regulars.

I have a humble proposition: perhaps you all could ask Giz to create more moderators? Even one new moderator could make a big difference. The job is not that hard, after all: read the forums, click to remove the toxic waste when you find it, and, well, that sums it up. Since I'm throwing ideas here, I will go all out and nominate brasca for the position. (Please note that I have no clue whether brasca would be interested or not -- this is just an impromptu suggestion.) My reasons: brasca is active every day, reads and writes in all three forums (Ma3, DC, SotR) that need policying, and has always been an example of respect and civility towards the authors, the characters and the fellow fans. That's the right profile to a T.

I'll stop here and leave the rest to y'all. Me, one who has left the forum, shouldn't really be speaking. Bye bye, everyone. (I know, I know, I had already said a final goodbye in my previous message, and look at me now. But this time it's my last post for realz.)
We, the old ghosts of Pizen Bluff, who still roam about this dead forum screaming imprecations at the characters and whatnot.

odalzara
Posts: 14
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 12:33 pm

Re: 23-06-18 Gotta little ketchup

Post by odalzara » Sun Aug 12, 2018 5:41 pm

TCampbell wrote:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 7:00 pm
TCampbell wrote:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 2:48 pm
To me, the MA3 cast has its good points and bad like most people, but there aren't any I consider hate-worthy.

Except Nathan and Yvan.
Spidrift wrote:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 5:53 pm
Am I the only reader to find Takeru far more disgusting than either of those two?
I can see the argument. It kind of depends on how much you assume he knew about what his professional fetishism was doing to his family before things reached a crisis point. You might say "well, how could he not," but when a thing is your job, it starts feeling normal to you very quickly. We didn't end up showing a lot of him on panel (that idea that he and DiDi would start dating never went anywhere) so you're left to fill in some blanks there. It seems to me like Yuki's forgiveness of him is coming from a healthy place, so I'd probably say he's all right, morally speaking.

Though you may have meant "disgusting" in terms of the off-puttingness of his imagination, in which case I can't really disagree.
Spidrift wrote:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 5:53 pm
And I wish we would get the wrap-up arc for Dillon's comic already but that can keeps getting kicked further down the road.
If this strip is ends the arc, as does seem possible, well, I’m living in the wild and foolish hope that we might cut across there next.
(whistles)
Spidrift wrote:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 5:53 pm
Well, to start with, you probably need to show Zii actually expressing love for DiDi.
I mean...

Image

and more importantly...

Image

I won't ENTIRELY fail to consider this feedback as we try to stick the landing, here. But I'm also not going to be surprised if some readers refuse to be persuaded at this point, no matter what.
that's your problem campbell, you can't persuade the readers in a forum, you have to do it in the comic itself, you have to stop trying to "explain" the comic to your readers and star thinking better ways to handle the narrative, because a lot of people can't understand your characters motivations, that was always your weak point

Post Reply